Exploring the sprawling grounds of Hogwarts Legacy reveals numerous hidden quests, but few are as satisfying as decoding Arthur Plummly's hand-drawn treasure map. Initiated by speaking with Arthur outside the Charms classroom in the Astronomy Wing, this side quest challenges players to follow a series of visual landmarks rather than relying on explicit waypoint markers. Completing the journey grants a unique appearance reward and provides a classic scavenger hunt experience within the castle walls.

Starting the Quest and Examining the Map

To begin the quest titled Cache in the Castle, interact with Arthur Plummly near the Charms classroom. He hands you a piece of parchment displaying three distinct drawings representing key landmarks within Hogwarts. Examining the map carefully is essential, as each image directly corresponds to an architecture piece located in nearby wings.

Locating the Rhinoceros Skeleton and Fountain

From the Astronomy Wing, head down toward the Defense Against the Dark Arts tower to locate the first clue. You will quickly spot the massive Rhinoceros Skeleton display positioned prominently along the corridor floor. Following the stairs past the display leads down to the Transfiguration Courtyard, where the central Wyvern Fountain serves as the second landmark shown on Arthur's map.

Tracking Down the Painting and Using Accio

After reaching the courtyard, enter the North Hall and climb the stairs until you reach a large portrait of a snowy landscape. Checking daily gaming news guides can help players confirm they are in the correct stairwell if the layout feels confusing. Casting Accio on the handle at the top of the painting triggers a hidden doorway mechanism built into the wall frame.

Claiming the Treasure and Returning to Arthur

Behind the revealed painting lies a hidden chest containing the Historian's Uniform handle cosmetic item. Once you retrieve the reward, head back to the Astronomy Wing to inform Arthur of your discovery. Completing the conversation finishes the quest, awarding experience points and officially clearing the map from your inventory.